Welcome to Brunch Sayville
At Brunch Sayville, nestled in the heart of Sayville, NY, we celebrate the joy of brunch with a delightful fusion of comfort and creativity. Our cozy, eclectic atmosphere invites guests to savor homemade dishes like our famous Biscuits & Gravy and the fluffy Brown Butter Hoe Cakes. With a commitment to inclusive dining, we offer a range of vegan options and prioritize sustainability with reusable tableware. The warm, friendly staff, led by Michele and Laura, create an inviting ambiance where laughter and exceptional coffee thrive. Join us for a memorable brunch experience that feels like coming home.
Brunch Sayville: Reviews & Ratings
We had brunch today at this very cozy, eclectic gem. My husband had Biscuits and Gravy and he found it to be one of the most flavorful that he has ever had. The sausage was not the average. It was flavorful and tender. I had the Breakfast Pot Pie that was totally off the hook. The portions were huge. We weren't able to finish them so we brought them home. Laura, she is your greeter, hostess, server, and your in-house comic. The proprietor, Michele, is warm and gracious and also provides a touch of comic relief. The brew is outstanding. Delicious and fresh that leave you asking for more. I must comment on their creamer dispensers. They are in the shape of mini tea pots, they are adorable. Laura has named me the "Brunch Bandit" because she knows how much I like them. Both my husband and I have made this charming establishment our new brunch go too. Trust me, you will never leave hungry or disappointed. Signing off, Brunch Bandit
3.5/5 Not sure where all the bad reviews are coming from but this place is very VERY small. For parking don't even bother with their lot, park across the street. The ambiance is great. It's very cozy and gives sort of an Alice in wonderland vibe. It's very rustic and cute! The menu is limited and has seasonal/weekly specials so keep that in mind but the food was very good. It's definitely more expensive than other brunch spots on the island and nearby BUT they offer vegan and vegetarian options. I recommend giving this place a shot even if it's just to try their croissants!
It was nice hostess was pleasant and attentive. Location is very small. Not a lot of seating, it seems like a local spot. Menu was small as well. Maybe 8 drink options and 8 meal options. My friend and I enjoyed are time spent. Decor was nice food came out fast. My meal was decent. Not sure if I would go back.
Passed this place on the way home one day and wanted to try it. My girlfriend's and I went today and we were 100% pleased with everything! Walking in, it's small but absolutely adorable. It is handicap accessible and there is extra seating out back. Our waitress was very accommodating and helpful, our food (sorry no pictures) was incredible! I recommend the BYO I got eggs bacon and potatoes and it came with this thick homemade bread that was so good I've raved about it since I got home! While I would love to gate keep this one, I also want to tell everyone about it!!!
Super cute small brunch spot with well priced items. The staff was kind and courteous. The food was good, but nothing out of this world. I recommend the sandwich have smaller bread ratio and the cheese to be on its own, instead of mixed in with the eggs. I think it would elevate the sandwich. The coffee was delicious and we left waiting to try the strawberry poptart.
Cute little place for brunch. Fresh eggs and home baked breads. Limited seating but we hit the right time. Fresh flowers on the tablets and miniature tea pots for milk for the coffee. Decorated beautifully. Will be returning.
Location
-
32 Foster Ave, Sayville, NY 11782 Hotline: (631) 319-1556
Welcome to Brunch Sayville, a delightful culinary gem nestled at 32 Foster Ave in Sayville, NY. Specializing in breakfast and brunch, this quaint establishment has quickly become a local favorite, renowned for its cozy atmosphere and eclectic decor that transports you into a whimsical world akin to an Alice in Wonderland setting.
Brunch Sayville is not just any brunch spot; it’s a haven for food lovers, offering a menu rich in flavor and style. Each dish is carefully crafted with fresh ingredients, making even the simplest of meals an extraordinary experience. The star dishes, such as the Biscuits and Gravy and the Brown Butter Hoe Cakes, have earned rave reviews from customers who can’t help but rave about their delectable flavors and generous portions.
- Biscuits and Gravy: A crowd favorite featuring house-made sausage gravy over a freshly baked buttermilk biscuit, it’s a comfort food must-try that has left guests like Josephine M. singing its praises for its unique flavor profile.
- Brown Butter Hoe Cakes: Fluffy cornmeal pancakes drizzled with grape syrup—these lightly sweetened delights encapsulate everything you want in a brunch dish, combining comfort and indulgence.
- A Smattering: Perfectly cooked farm-fresh eggs paired with your choice of protein, morning potatoes, and griddled bread, this option ensures that every bite is a flavor-packed adventure.
Not only is the food exceptional, but the ambiance adds to the charm of Brunch Sayville. With both indoor and outdoor seating available, including areas that are dog-friendly, you can enjoy your meal in a setting that encourages relaxation and enjoyment. The covered outdoor seating is a perfect spot to savor your morning coffee while soaking in the sun.
Speaking of coffee, the freshly brewed drip coffee at Brunch Sayville is another highlight that should not be overlooked. Patrons note how the delightful brews enhance their meals and leave them craving more.
What truly sets Brunch Sayville apart is its congenial service. The staff, especially the vivacious Laura, provide a warm and welcoming experience that makes you feel like part of the family. Michele, the proprietor, embodies hospitality, adding a touch of humor that enhances your dining experience.
Despite its limited menu size, which has been noted by customers, the seasonal and weekly specials ensure there’s always something new to try. The inclusion of vegan options also makes it accessible for every dietary need. Visitors are encouraged to discover the hidden gems, like the delightful croissants or the delicious homemade biscuits and English muffins.
If you’re looking for a unique brunch experience, I wholeheartedly recommend making Brunch Sayville your next destination. With a charming setting, exceptional food, and friendly service, you’re sure to leave happy—and possibly with a new title, just like the “Brunch Bandit” herself!
